OSCARS WATCH 2026—'F1' and Persisting Assumptions of Quality

OSCARS WATCH 2026—'F1' and Persisting Assumptions of Quality

This piece is part of a series of critical responses based on the films nominated for the 98th Academy Awards. In this contribution, Duncan McLean reflects on F1: The Movie being nominated for Best Picture and how this provokes persistent assumptions about quality associated with the Oscars.

Read More

OSCARS WATCH 2025 – Political Fears and Fantasies in Edward Berger’s Conclave

OSCARS WATCH 2025 – Political Fears and Fantasies in Edward Berger’s Conclave

This post is part of a series of critical responses to the films nominated for Best Picture at the 97th Academy Awards. The political thriller is a genre that most effectively exists in close proximity to history. Regardless of whether its narratives are based on actual events, they draw on the political fears and paranoias of an era. It is why, historically, we have seen the genre congregate around moments of significant political tension or fear. We live in such an era now, with the divisive unorthodoxy of Trump being but the most prominent of numerous international examples of the growing divide between left and right and a breaking down of previously accepted political norms. That being the case, it should not be surprising to see a political thriller, Edward Berger’s Conclave, find its way into what is a notably political Best Picture field for this year’s Academy Awards.

Read More