Learning in a Participatory Culture: A Conversation About New Media and Education (Part One)

A few weeks ago, I received a message in the mail from Ariel Glazer at University of Buenos Aires sharing this video, which remixed some footage from the interview I gave to the producers of Digital Nation. In many ways, it captures some of my core themes and concerns better than the PBS documentary and in the process, it helps us make connections with a range of other conversations taking place around the world about New Media Literacies.

When I taught my New Media Literacies class last semester at USC, I asked my students to interview a student or teacher about the ways that the issues in our class impacted their lives. Because these students came from many different countries, we ended up with glimpses of what was taking in classrooms from the Laplands to India, from Bulgaria to India. In almost every case, the young people interviewed described deeply meaningful forms of learning which were taking place through their engagement with affinity groups and social networks online, yet they each described school practices which shut off that learning once they entered the classroom. The teachers, on the other hand, talked about struggling to keep up with their students, about a lack of formal training to help them make the transitions being demanded, and about their fears of losing control over their classroom.

I wanted to stress the international nature of these exchanges because this week I am going to be sharing with you an extended interview which I did with Pillar Lacasa, a Spanish researcher, who has spent two blocks of time as a visiting scholar in the Comparative Media Studies Program and whose work has been featured on this blog before. Lacasa is a close friend and she knows enough about my work to ask questions which help position it for readers back in Spain. Since this interview will appear later this week in Spanish in Cuadernos de Pedagogia, I asked her if I could share the original English language version here. I hope that this will be of interest especially to the many parents and educators who read this blog and may represent a response to some of the issues raised in the Digital Nation documentary.

Children and young people like to spend their free time in front of the screen. Could you give us some good reasons to that could persuade educators to introduce new media and screens in schools

At the end of the day, it isn’t about the technology. It certainly isn’t about the screen per se. It is about the informational affordances and cultural practices which have taken shape around the computer and other interactive technologies. It isn’t about the computer replacing the book. It is about a world where students learn with a book in one hand and a mouse in the other, rather than one where they are taught that book culture is so fragile it needs to be protected from the computer.

Jenna McWilliams, until recently, part of our Project NML staff, writes powerfully about reading with a mouse in your hand. She tells us that teachers often encourage students to read with a pencil in their hands — not simply letting the words pass over their eyeballs but critically engaging with them, taking notes, asking questions, critiquing as they go. When students read with a mouse in their hands, they take this one step further: they assume that they must actively respond to what’s been put in front of them; they are poised to participate; they take responsibility over the quality of information and correct it publically if it is wrong.

Yochai Benkler, author of The Wealth of Networks, tells us we respond to the culture differently when we see it through the eyes of a participant rather than a consumer. And it is this participatory culture which has been facilitated by the new digital media in a way that stretches far beyond the imagination of previous generations.

Reading your book I noticed that you establish an interesting distinction between mass media and technology. How do you understand both of these concepts?

For me, a medium is more than simply a technology. It also includes the social and cultural practices that have grown up around us. So, when we talk about television, we are not simply talking about an electronic appliance; we are talking about the programming strategies and conventions which have emerged to shape our experience of television and we are referencing the particular mind set that has evolved around watching television often in our homes with little chance of engaging with its contents directly or publically. When we are talking about the internet, we are talking about all of the activities we perform through this new information infrastructure and the mindset which emerges through our ongoing engagement and participation in the great public conversation that emerges through it.

Beyond the individual medium there is a media ecology — all of the different kinds of communications systems which surround us and through which we live our everyday lives. Right now, for example, we inhabit a world where mass media, top down systems of communications, co-exist with grassroots media, which enable much broader opportunities for our participation. We are just starting to understand what happens when these two systems collide.

You introduce the idea of a Participatory Culture in relation to new media. Can you explain the relation between the two concepts?

Participatory culture didn’t begin or end with the internet. Most of what I am describing as participatory culture can be found in any thriving folk culture. At its best, a folk culture is defined through the expanding opportunities for participation. Everyone who wants to join is accepted. Everyone who has something to contribute is embraced. Experienced members share what they know through informal mentorship with newcomers because it expands the expressive resources of the community. The exchange of folk artifacts is reciprocal, based on the ideals of a gift economy, rather than hierarchical or commercial.

This idea of dispersed expression broke down in the 20th century as most forms of cultural production became professionalized and commercialized. We moved into a world where we consumed but did not produce the resources of our culture — never totally but largely. Throughout that period, though, there were all kinds of underground and grassroots practices which held onto the idea of shared cultural expression and participation. These practices have re-emerged and gained greater public visibility in the era of Flickr and YouTube.

These technologies have brought cultural expression down to a human scale; they have placed the exchange of stories or songs in a social context; and they have opened up a space where all of us can be welcomed as potential participants. All of the research shows that the communities of practice which grow up around this participatory culture are powerful sites of pedagogy, fueled by passion and curiosity and by a desire to share what we learn and think with others. As with older folk cultures, informal pedagogies thrive as people get together to learn based on shared interests rather than fixed roles and responsibilities.

Participatory Culture could be relate with a Collective Intelligence as present in the media too?

In a networked society, literacy is a social skill not simply an individual competency. Understanding how information circulates becomes as important as knowing how to put your ideas into words, sounds, or images. Creation is iterative: we reshape what we’ve created in response to critical feedback from others in an ongoing process of innovation and refinement.

There are new forms of collective authorship which have emerged around principles of collective intelligence. Take Wikipedia for example, where any given entry may have multiple authors, each vetting and refining what was written before, each adding what they know to what others have already contributed. This is different from traditional forms of individual expertise and autonomous learning.

Pierre Levy tells us that in a networked society, nobody knows everything (Forget about the ideal of the Renaissance Man), everybody knows something (expand the range of possible expertises) and what any given member of the community knows is available to the group as a whole as needed. The result is an ethics of information — an obligation to share what you know with the group, a need to respect yet critically engage with multiple ways of knowing, an active push to embrace diversity because it expands the creative and knowledge capacity of your network.

We are evolving towards this much more robust information system where groups working together can solve problems that are far more complex than can be confronted by individuals. And schools can actively prepare students for such a world — by allowing them to develop and refine their individualized expertise, by providing complex problems which require collective effort to resolve, by teaching them the ethics involved in working in such a highly collaborative and open-ended context. Right now, schools are often using group work but not in ways which encourage real collaboration or shared expertise — in part because they still assume a world where every student knows everything rather than one where different kinds of knowledge come together towards shared ends.

The project New Media Literacy relates participation to new forms of literacy?

What we are proposing is an expanded conception of literacy which includes all of the ways which we communicate our ideas to each other. This concept moves beyond the idea of critical consumption which is often what people call media literacy. You wouldn’t consider someone literate if they could read but not write text and we shouldn’t consider someone literate if they can consume but not produce media. Over the past fifty years, we have expanded the resources through which humans can communicate with each other, in some cases making tools like video cameras more widely available, and in others creating an infrastructure which allows anyone who goes online a chance to communicate their thoughts to the world.

Schools need to prepare young people to use these new resources creatively, effectively, and responsibly if they are going to prepare them for the lives they will lead in the 21st century. Such power can be under-used if they are not taught to use it creatively or effectively; it can be abused if they are not taught to use it responsibly. Teachers need to recognize both the risks and the possibilities of these new opportunities for human expression.

Comments

  1. eyetryhard.wordpress.com says:

    I agree with what Lacasa said about schools needing to include exercises for students where they can work in a collective effort. The collaborative environment of social media only seems to be growing. As a college student studying communications, it’s almost a requirement that students have blogs or some sort of online presence. I went to a career panel a couple of months ago and all of the panelists, who happened to be recruiters, said companies are looking for people who are familiar and active on social media. If schools include more collaborative working among students, it well better prepare them for when they finish school and begin looking for work.

  2. IP PBX says:

    Active participation in social media by the majority of the community is because of its freedom of expressions and acceptance. Every individual get an area to be active in the social media and get the appreciation for his work. Such changing trend should be accepted in the right way. Students should be encouraged not just to copy and paste but to create the world with their own imagination and efforts. It is rightly suggested by the article that a responsible, effective and collective use of such powerful tool should be encouraged in the students by the teacher.

  3. Rca Ieftin says:

    The movie is very relevant to this “Facebook era”. I am negatively impressed by what is happen in this moment. In fact the real society cannot be a society based just on fake social contacts (like the contacts from Facebook, for example). I am glad to see that the “old” generation is still able to show the real and good way to a correct society.

  4. Henry Jenkins is talented writer.Every time i read his blog got surprise.I liked his way of presentation.He also focuses on interesting and informative issues.I said my other friends to be bookmarked with his blog and they did.His posts make me understand and encourages me to have my own.

  5. rohmansah says:
  6. Sofia says:

    Henry Jenkins is talented writer.Every time i read his blog got surprise.I liked his way of presentation

    Best regards, Sofia, CEO of how to setup iscsi

  7. candice says:

    Howdy! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group? There’s a lot of people that I think would really enjoy your content. Please let me know. Thank you

    Dolce Gabbana

    Dolce Vita

    Ecco Golf Shoes

  8. diaperpal says:

    Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with the pictures on this blog loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any feed-back would be greatly appreciated.

    springboost shoes

    MBT Shoes

    MBT Shoes Reviews

  9. akshay321 says:

    A very touching story, share with us! Thank you, nice article, I love it. Great thanks for sharing this article post. how to stop snoring

    baby shower cakes

    San Diego Homes

  10. Heart says:

    New media is developing very quickly and the new decisons appear each day, that rocks!

    3 years ago I couldn’t even imagine that it will be possible to watch full tv show episodes online

  11. hushcat says:

    Home renovations Costs

    The collaborative environment of social media only seems to be growing. As a college student studying communications, it’s almost a requirement that students have blogs or some sort of online presence.

  12. george bil says:

    To be honest, I even could not imagine how hard it is to find decent piece of info on the above topic. It took me a couple of hours before I came across your site. No doubt, it is the best freely available source! Thanks for it!

    replica watches

  13. mark says:

    THis is so great informations. I will come back

    If you have free time, please visit Padded BrasLong Denim Skirts.

    Thanks

  14. akshay321 says:

    It was nice to read your blog. The thoughts are very well laid out and it was refreshing to read. Top online Casinos

  15. jaclyn says:

    I really enjoyed reading your blog. I found it very useful and informational!

    revitalash reviews

  16. Game Tester says:

    i like it very much, way to go dude:

    yeast infection is terrible, Yeast Infection but i have a solution to yeast infection

  17. drgreen says:

    Since natural supplements are not regulated, many

    manufacturers meclizine 125 mg

    are merely marketers hawking miracle products that either metformin 850 mg

    don’t contain the ingredients they claim to or metoclopramide 5 mg

    don’t offer any health benefits whatsoever. omeprazole 20 mg capsules

    Look over their web site for company information, side effects of simvastatin 20 mg

    product information, voltaren 75 mg manufacturing procedures, etc.

  18. drgreen says:

    One of the most popular questions cilostazol 100 mg

    we receive here is “Where do I buy health pills?” coq 10 200 mg

    Short and to the point. Well, estradiol 1 mg

    we’ve researched dozens of health supplement etodolac 200 mg

    providers and have discovered how you can find glucosamine sulfate 1500 mg

    the highest quality products you can buy. lamisil 250 mg

  19. drgreen says:

    So we set out to find a supplement that female viagra uk

    included ALL of these therapeutic nutrients fertomid 50 mg

    in one formula. That way we could get all of actos 15 mg

    the benefits we were getting from alendronate sodium 70 mg

    taking these nutrients separately without

    taking dozens of different cefixime 400 mg

    cefpodoxime 200 mg

    pills, tablets and powders.

  20. drgreen says:

    One of the most popular questions betagan we receive here is “Where do I buy health pills?” betoptic Short and to the point.

    Well, blopress we’ve researched dozens of health supplement cefaclor

    providers and have discovered how you can find colospa

    the highest quality products you can buy. combivir

  21. drgreen says:

    Since natural supplements are not regulated, many

    manufacturers clomid no prescription

    are merely marketers hawking miracle products that either clomid pills

    don’t contain the ingredients they claim to or clomid tablets

    don’t offer any health benefits whatsoever. evista online

    Look over their web site for company information, evista pills

    product information, evista tablets manufacturing procedures, etc.

  22. Clark05 says:
  23. hushcat says:

    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with extra information? It is extremely helpful for me.

    how to win the lottery

  24. ad says:

    Thank you for providing such great a article.

    ppc advertising | ppc | ppc review

  25. akshay321 says:

    It was nice to read your blog. The thoughts are very well laid out and it was refreshing to read. I was able to find the information that I was looking for. I just wanted to leave a comment as a token of appreciation. Thanks for sharing this on the Net Car Insurance Comparison | croatia cruises | menu icons

  26. rachelhunter says:

    Hello again Henry. What a great post/video. I absolutely agree with your point about collective intelligence, this is what learning is all about and the web is the best tool to tap into that. Many thanks, Rachel – electrical supplies | s172 road traffic act | caravan insurance

  27. rachelhunter says:

    Do schools and colleges really ban the use of Wikipedia, that is just ludicrous! I think that type of media should be embraced in the school environment not restricted, very strange….

    Thanks for sharing Henry.

    christening gift ideas | tattoo machines

  28. subh says:

    I love your site, you give so many great tips especially since I use word press and the plug-in section of your blog is great. some of the tips i get here I can’t find anywhere else. Thanks

    icon editor

  29. fuihuuhuo says:

    To be honest, I even could not imagine how hard it is to find decent piece of info on the above topic. It took me a couple of hours before I came across your site. No doubt, it is the best freely available source! Thanks for it!

    Penis Enlargers

  30. Robinson says:

    have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorites blog site list and will be checking back soon. Please check out my site as well and let me know what you think.

    Child Behavior Problems

    Potty Training Boys

    Potty Training Tips

    Potty Training Regression

  31. aqua says:

    welcome great web for shopping text to speech and rolex replica

    Shop and find the lowest prices on products from louis vuitton outlet. Price comparison shopping, product reviews, and armani watch – all the tools to help make wow gold simple

  32. taminadastan says:

    Im impressed, I must say. Very rarely do I come across a site thats both informative and entertaining, and let me tell you, youve hit the nail on the head.

    business continuity

    watch movie trailers

    real estate property

    health care products

  33. Ramz Leena says:

    Hay, Henry Jenkins.

    It is very good article about Learning and New media Education.

    Where is the Part 2.

    I Cant find the link

    Jessica

    Best ankle strengthening exercises

  34. Ramz Leena says:

    Hay, Henry Jenkins.

    Thanks for this Great Article .

    But where is the second part.

    Jessica

    Best ankle strengthening exercises

  35. yangrui says:

    Despite the fact that most of designer sunglasses the aforementioned retails stores have an e-commerce site, most like the convenience of cheap mbt shopping these stores from within one location. An online shopping mall offers all that plus offers rebates for mac palette eyeshadow shopping with them. Often time shopping with them also allows for discount christian louboutin free shipping. There may be other online shopping malls, that offer the same products, but if you look closely, sometimes the products actually come from these major stores. Often times, by coming from these stores adds to gucci bags the shipping and handling fees.

  36. mortgage refinance says:

    nice aricle i like it.It is very good article about Learning and New media Education.Heloc rates and bad credit mortgages

  37. mark says:

    THis is so great informations. I will come back

    If you have free time, please visit:

    Notebook News

    Laptop News

    HTC Android Smartphone

    Slim Digital Camera

    Android News

    Moto Droid

    Gadget and Tech news

  38. rockingdavid says:

    this is so exciting and informative for me really… because I have never had any idea of these things that in this modern world we are going to be in that kind of technology filed where we have to be best on our capabilities to success and stay at top. I have been always a fan of innovation and new things in life so doin these kind of courses like CCNA, MCSE and other certifications which can not only help you for your future but also makes you unique in this field as well.. so very happy to be part of this and want you guys to also have a look at them because once you will join it and have a study on these, you surely gona like it and appreciate the effort…this is all what I can say, rest of you will decide. thanks!!!

    network+ certification | microsoft mcp | 350-001 exam | VCP-410 | 640-802 exam | 70-680 dumps | 70-640 exam | 642-813 | 646-205 | 642-902

  39. swiftapp says:
  40. The movie is very relevant to this “Facebook era”. I am negatively impressed by what is happen in this moment. In fact the real society cannot be a society based just on fake social contacts (like the contacts from Facebook, for example). I am glad to see that the “old” generation is still able to show the real and good way to a correct society.

  41. SEO says:

    Nice video, I love everything you told on this video very much.

    Thanks.

  42. blogging says:
  43. hama says:

    We took a subway underneath the xx River which separates Padong from the main part of Shanghai. The full length of the ride is accompanied by flashing lazer lights, inflated figures, retro electronica music, and a cryptic narration.

    Bankruptcy lawyer New York

  44. wizard of oz says:

    This post was very well written, and it also contains a lot of useful facts. I appreciated your professional way of writing this post. Thanks, you have made it very easy for me to understand.

    snow cone syrup

    snow cone supplies

    snow cone flavors

    snow cone machine

    wizard of oz

    wizard of oz books

  45. free games says:
  46. Maria swan says:

    Nice to very useful info for me.Because i’m new in blogging and i’m need good tutorial like your post.

    sheds

  47. guest says:

    Very useful information, thanks so much Genuine Ugg Boots

  48. Mahandra kushwaha says:

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful. I bookmarked this blog a while ago because of the useful content and I am never being disappointed. Keep up the good work
    Custom Homes Bastrop

  49. Maria says:

    Wow. Truly amazing post. Very well written, precise and to the point. I have just bookmarked this URL, will come and check for more stuff later. Thanks for sharing.

    Cambridge Life Solutions Canada

  50. rufus says:

    truly amazing post! I'm happy smart people have blogs so we can read their thoughts.

    YouTube mp4 http://convertyoutubetomp4.net

  51. baonam says:

    Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing problem with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody getting equivalent rss problem? Anyone who is aware of kindly respond. Thnkx kidney symptoms

  52. pagerang says:

    good looking
    i like it
    it is very useful and information

  53. Lisa Taylor says:

    Thank you for bringing this to our attention. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end.

    homeowners insurance florida

  54. Fleshlight says:

    Some genuinely interesting information, well written. Glad to be one of the visitors of your site.
    fleshlight

  55. Lana Grossa says:

    Great content man, it's hard to come by something that useful these days. Really appreciate the time and effort you put into this.
    Lana Grossa

  56. Garagen says:

    Perfectly written content, really enjoyed reading through. Garagen

  57. Fertiggaragen says:

    I like the efforts you have put in this, thanks for all the great articles. http://www.exklusiv-garagen.de“ rel=”nofollow”>Fertiggaragen

  58. Suzanne says:

    I want to say that I don't think I've read anything so true in a long time. You've got a lot of great ideas, a great deal of perspective. Onlinerechtsberatung

  59. Dry Fruit says:

    I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

  60. Awesome picture.It,s so interesting and remember able moment when all friends are together and have a lot of fun.

  61. good video

  62. jessica smith says:

    Oh my benefits! an amazing write-up dude. Thanks a lot However I i'm experiencing downside to ur feed . Don’t know the reason why Unable to enroll in it. Is there anybody obtaining equivalent google problem? Anyone who is aware of please respond. I thought this was a useful submit and I think it is quite easy to see from the other remarks as well that the post will be well written in addition to useful. My partner and i bookmarked this website a while ago due to the useful content material and I am never being dissatisfied. Keep up the nice work. Thank you for bringing this particular to our focus. I want to convey my affection of your publishing skill as well as ability to help to make readers go through from the beginning on the end.

    Indoor wall fountains , ” rel=”nofollow”>tabletop fountains