Counting on Twitter: Harvard’s Web Ecology Project (Part One)

Anyone who has read my blog long knows that I am not big on counting things. Some of it is that I have math anxiety — a serious vulnerability for someone who spent the first 20 years of his career at MIT! Some of it is that I think people often act as if counting things is the same thing as analyzing things or that the only things that count are things that came be counted. I often wage a one-man struggle against the push to quantify the universe — perhaps as if (arbitrary science fiction reference warning) the world would end if we could just capture all of the billions of names of God. That said, I am finding myself mellow more than a little now that I am at USC, am watching my former graduate students struggle to grasp quantitative methods, and getting to know some of my office mates and colleagues who count things for a living.

And there is a particularly value in trying to understand the scale on which certain changes in our communication environment are occurring — at least to capture some order of their magnitude. And that’s why I have been following with some interest the emergence of a research team at Harvard focused on understanding Twitter and its place in the “web ecology.” Many members of the team are graduate students I worked with in a range of capacities during my time at MIT and have come to value their insights into digital media. Their data is already helping me to reframe some of the thinking I am doing about spreadable media and knowing how many people come to this blog now through my tweets, my bet is that you will find what they are doing interesting as well. In this first installment, the responses come from Dharmishta Rood, who I met through the Knight news challenge a few years ago and who took several of my classes during my final year at MIT. I featured one of her essays on the blog last spring. Next time, she will be joined by some other members of the research team.

What do you mean by web ecology? What does the name of your group tell us about the assumptions guiding your research?

We summarize our research by the statement that Web Ecology studies the relationship of the nature of data and the behavior of actors on the internet.

Web Ecology as a field, rather than focusing on the Internet from various fields such as Sociology, Humanities, Business or Media Studies, focuses on the Web itself, combining methodologies from multiple, often interrelated disciplines, to decipher activity online both quantitatively and qualitatively. In our personal research practices we frequently use large-scale data mining to inform our research questions and to further our understanding about the cultures and communities evident online. In addition to providing quantitative analysis about the social layer of the web, we see our role as Web Ecologists to provide tools for other Web Ecologists in an open manner for the community of researchers. We also see the advantageous position of this type of resarch for businesses interested in marketing and online presence.

What can you tell us about the core methodology you are applying to understanding how Twitter works?

We try to break down Twitter into quantifiable interactions. We understand that there are many factors outside of Twitter–both time specific, such as breaking news, the hour of a TV show or a holiday, but also new trends and information being spread throughout the web. We try to look at all of it within the ecosystem of Twitter itself. At Web Ecology we try to look at what we can measure–namely retweets, mentions, @replies, #hashtags and common keywords within the sea of tweets.

We understand that the web is constrained by various forces and configurations. Rather than a utopian or deterministic perspective, Web Ecology recognizes that the web is not limitless or truly divorceable from various geographic, social, historical, and other realities.

Web Ecology endorses the systematic creation and testing of models, which leads us to a heavily quantitative approach, that can then be paired with a qualitatitive exploration of these findings. We also don’t overlook Internet phenomena as transient cultural fads–we see cultural creation on the Internet as impartially as possible, and also that code and users are part of an inseparable aggregate web phenomenon.

Some of your earliest results dealt with the role of Twitter in the aftermath of the Iran elections. What kinds of data emerged from your investigation? What did that tell us we didn’t already know about the twitter traffic surrounding these events?

Our report cites much of the popular media that both creates the term yet also criticizes the hasty declaration of a “Twitter Revolution” in Iran.

Using 12 keywords and hashtags, we found that 58% of relevant twitter conversation did NOT contain the common hashtag #iranelection. This allowed us to get a much more comprehensive overview of the Twittersphere during the Iranian election.

One of the most interesting findings to emerge out of the report were these two facts in conjunction: The top 10% of users in our study account for 65.5% of total tweets and one in four tweets were retweet of another user’s content, showing that the users who tweet the most are not always the most influential.

twitter mj_dies(2).jpg

You’ve also looked at the Twitter traffic following Michael Jackson’s death. What similarities and differences did you find in the discussion surrounding these two events?

Similarly to the Iran election, with Michael Jackson’s death on Twitter there were many keywords. One of the most interesting findings was the trajectory of each event over the Twittersphere. In the case of Michael Jackson’s death, there were over 279,000 tweets within the first hour of mainstream news reports of Jackson’s death, whereas with the Iranian election, there were 2,024,166 tweets total (over eighteen days), but never more than 17,500 tweets in any given hour. These tweets fluctuated during times of unrest.

Since the excitement on twitter decreased over time, especially after the first hour, the type of content was inherently very different. We spent time hand-coding tweets (in the Social Science sense, having individuals read and analyze the tweets according to certain metrics) rather than strictly doing data analysis. The Michael Jackson report sought to understand sentiment on Twitter, rather than the trajectory of a real-time event spanning many days.

twitter mj_iran(2).jpg

How important is retweeting to the ecology of the web?

Within twitter specifically, retweeting is only one of the many ways people can interact with content. It becomes important when new audiences see content from users they do not follow, but another important feature of Twitter is search. Users following a particular topic of interest can come across new content to consume and share.

What do you think Twitter is doing that is different from other kinds of social networks?

Twitter allows users to follow one another asymmetrically, meaning that users do not have to follow those that follow them. From this an interesting dynamic emerges wherein follower counts are meaningful in a separate way than the number and type of people a user follows. A user is often valued more for the amount of followers–an account with immensely more users they are following than follow them is likely spam, whereas a user like Ashton Kutcher (@aplusk) only follows ~300 users but has almost 4,000,000 followers.

Twitter, as it’s been deemed many times over is a “micro blogging service,” meaning the updates contain news and information like blogs, but with many fewer characters. This micro-update style is now a relevant part of other social networks, both during and after the increase of Twitter’s userbase.

Dharmishta Rood is Director of Research Relations at the Web Ecology Project and a recent graduate Harvard’s Graduate School of Education. Her work deals with large scale and interpersonal communication systems like social networks and news. These types of platforms allow users to generate and consume information in ways that further social connections and learning. She is a 2008 Knight News Challenge winner for Populous Project, a free and open-source platform for online news, holds a degree in Design | Media Arts from UCLA and is a Fellow at the Center for Future Civic Media. She tweets @dharmishta and blogs at dharmishta.com.


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Comments

  1. Thanks for this article and the promotion of web ecology. At linkfluence, our opinion and market research agency, we call people in charge of exploring, observing and analysing social web contents : ecologists (écologues in French) since our debuts in 2006 !

  2. Payday Loans says:

    Do you need a Payday Loan? If so, come on over and check out all the payday loan options on my website. Payday loans are exactly what most people need to get through the month. They help you pay your bills and keep creditors off your back. And the loans are really easy to get. Never again will you need to spend all your time trying to get a personal loan when all you really need is a high quality payday loan. Don’t take our word for it though, check out the hundreds of online reviews we have of payday companies near you.

  3. Sofia says:

    Thank you!

    Best regards, Sofia, CEO of best iscsi san

  4. Simon Smith says:

    Wow this post is awesome! I actually learn a lot! Your blog is just too interesting to be missed. Such knowledge about this subject, continue, I’m here reading you!

    Thanks this great article!

    Simon Smith pres at

  5. Simon Smith says:

    Wow this post is awsome! I actually just learn a lot! Your blog is just too important to be missed. You’ve got so much to say, such knowledge about this subject, I’m here reading you! Thanks this great article! Simon Smith pres at Articles about health, fitness, wellness, success and lifestyle

  6. alas says:

    Considerably, the post is really the freshest on this worthy topic. I agree with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your approaching updates. Just saying thanks will not just be enough, for the extraordinary clarity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates. cigarettes online

  7. Louis Vuitton, the world-renowned brands, but also for muxury a consideration. For these replica louis vuitton,replica Louis Vuitton Handbags absolute comw of NPK’s high quality and fashion design, but also added the popular bags for sale. There are also many copies of replica louis vuitton Handbag to sell in the market, so when you choose not to pay attention to your luggage. In addition, all of these Louis Vuitton Handbags,also used the same material,designed by replica louis vuitton of these condescending, and large bags. In short, all of these replica Louis Vuitton Handbags to provide you with the replica louis vuitton Handbag and so on. Speaking of Louis Vuitton Handbags,people know, talk, and only those women who use this wealth of high-priced bags. In the winter, it is said, the work of louis vuitton travel luggage and louis vuitton men bags in these cities on the market very well.

    CHEN

  8. Robinson says:

    have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorites blog site list and will be checking back soon. Please check out my site as well and let me know what you think.

    Child Behavior Problems

    Potty Training Boys

    Potty Training Tips

    Potty Training Regression

  9. aqua says:

    welcome great web for shopping text to speech and rolex replica

    Shop and find the lowest prices on products from louis vuitton outlet. Price comparison shopping, product reviews, and armani watch – all the tools to help make wow gold simple

  10. mila says:

    The article was very informative . Thank you! I like your blog.

  11. yangrui says:

    Other kinds of carrera sunglasses stores are big-box stores, convenience stores, dollar stores, hypermarkets, or department stores that sold off a broad range of cheap mbt shoes products regardless of having any similarity to each other. With the advent of mac cosmetics modern technology like telephone, television and Internet, the shopping has become much easier and is often referred as home shopping. Electronic commerce in combination with the business-to-consumer commerce schemes has made the system of christian louboutin home shopping possible for everyone in which a buyer can make purchases via online shopping, mail order and shopping channels, etc. Sometimes ice-cream trucks and peddlers pass through your neighborhood also offer goods and services to you. There are some shopping seasons especially on the eve of gucci outlet Christmas, during which each and every person likes to go shopping for various needs and purposes.

  12. Pikavippi says:

    Very interesting article and piece of research as well. These kind of insights could be very beneficial for internet marketers who are trying to understand how social interactions work online. I guess Michael Jackson’s death was moving certain fans a lot more than Iranian election and it happened at a certain moment, whereas the election didn’t struck like a lightning.

  13. mortgage refinance says:

    The article was very informative . Thank you! I like it.Heloc rates and bad credit mortgages

  14. karen01 says:

    Was pleased reading about

    buying thesis

  15. liumao says:

    hey i acttually like this blog cause its awesome make more blog interesting thanks

    wisefollowbdsarticlesfish

  16. rockingdavid says:

    this is so exciting and informative for me really… because I have never had any idea of these things that in this modern world we are going to be in that kind of technology filed where we have to be best on our capabilities to success and stay at top. I have been always a fan of innovation and new things in life so doin these kind of courses like CCNA, MCSE and other certifications which can not only help you for your future but also makes you unique in this field as well.. so very happy to be part of this and want you guys to also have a look at them because once you will join it and have a study on these, you surely gona like it and appreciate the effort…this is all what I can say, rest of you will decide. thanks!!!

    70-642 practice exam | SY0-201 | 640-822 exam | 350-030 pdf | 70-649 exam | PMI-001 exam | 642-832 | 70-662 | 1Y0-A18 | 640-816 exam

  17. Hotels in Ostend says:

    Nicely done mate. I agree most of what was written right here & this would certainly make myself wanna return to your blog! Bookmarked!

    Ostend Hotels

  18. ferfgrg says:

    Are you acquainted with the liveliest mode add-on? If not, do you want to know about it? Truly speaking, this costs none early than Swissarmy Convoy Watches the least bit because they are your liveliest mode accoutrements today.[url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-chronograph-men-watches-819.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Chronograph men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-chronograph-men-watches-820.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Chronograph men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-competition-40-men-watches.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Competition 40 men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-competition-40-men-watches-824.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Competition 40 men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-competition-40-men-watches-827.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Competition 40 men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-competition-40-men-watches-828.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Competition 40 men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-competition-40-men-watches-834.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Competition 40 men watches[/url]

    [url=http://www.soreplicawatches.com/replica-corum-admiral-s-cup-competition-40-men-watches-835.html]Replica Corum Admiral\’s Cup Competition 40 men watches[/url] Why constitutes it so? Realistically speaking, replica watches are your most captivating and vivacious fashion adjunct on account of their sizzling and sensational manners.

  19. hama says:

    Interesting post and thanks for sharing. Some things in here I have not thought about before.Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written.will be referring a lot of friends about this.Keep blogging

    Bankruptcy attorney NY

  20. Flowerflora2011 says:

    Canada Goose Expedition Parka I promise you that – nor Dad, her mate, or the goslings, Horatio, Canada Goose Freestyle Vest Cinnamon and Zack, Canada Goose Snow Mantra Parka an extended family of resident geese in the Birmingham area whose habits I've been researching for three years. We've been on many journeys, Zo and I, Canada Goose Mens Vest traipsing through nearby woods or sitting near the lake just watching the world go by. Canada Goose Expedition Parka I met Zo as I was jogging at a city park and within months was drawn into her world. Canada Goose Freestyle Vest When the park got too crowded, Canada Goose Parkas the family would head for a nearby cemetery. The tombstones were their refuge; the geese themselves had become my solace from a wild and desperate world. Canada Goose Snow Mantra Parka No iPods, no video games, no cell phones, no laptops – just simple pleasures like solitude and silence. Now it's the Fish and Wildlife Service that I worry about. Federal officials want to relinquish their authority over resident geese to the states. Canada Goose Mens Vest What that really means is that geese along three major flyways, including the Mississippi flyway, where Alabama is located, can be slaughtered without a federal permit – and its cumbersome red tape.

  21. Adunhgs says:

    It’s hard to search out knowledgeable people on this subject, but you sound like you already know

    what you’re speaking about! Thanks
    Physician Assistant

  22. Pikavippi says:

    Intresting looking graphs. Need to doublecheck the info.

    Antti
    pikavippi

  23. Jaymin says:

    thanks for good info….

  24. Klavis says:
  25. sujitroy says:

    Dharmishta Rood is Director of Research Relations at the Web Ecology Project and a recent graduate Harvard's Graduate School of Education. Her work deals with large scale and interpersonal communication systems like social networks and news. These types of platforms allow users to generate and consume information in ways that further social connections and learning. She is a 2008 Knight News Challenge winner for Populous Project, a free and open-source platform for online news, holds a degree in Design | Media Arts from UCLA and is a Fellow at the Center for Future Civic Media. She tweets @dharmishta and blogs at

  26. Juhani Viksten says:

    good data.
    pikavippi

  27. panax says:

    but you sound like you already know