Akoha– A Direct Action Game?

For those of you interested in the work I’ve been discussing over the past week or so on civics and participatory culture, let me strongly recommend checking out the blog which is being run by the graduate students associated with our CivicPaths research group. Recent discussions there have included considerations of zombies as potential political metaphors, reflections on the nature of “engaged scholarship,” thoughts on what we can learn from the Tea Party movement, and information about playful forms of civic education around economic literacy.

Each of these pieces reflects the work of a particular PhD candidate, mostly from the Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism, though some come from the School of Cinematic Arts or elsewhere at USC. The students post about once a week and are doing a good job of reflecting the kinds of conversations we are having with guest speakers, interview subjects, and amongst ourselves as we try to make sense of the intersection of youth, new media, and political participation.

Today, I am re-posting one of the recent blog entries — some thoughts about how serious gaming might foster greater civic participation by Benjamin Stokes. Stokes has been deeply committed to the concept of games for change for over a decade, first as part of the leadership of the organization with the same name, then as a foundation officer at MacArthur working with Connie Yowell on the Digital Media and Learning Initiative, and now as a PhD candidate at USC. I have been lucky to have chances to work with him in each of these contexts. He’s deeply earnest and serious-minded about how the world of play might influence our civic and social lives. He models what I admire most about my new USC cohort — the ability to merge theoretical rigor with practices designed to have an impact in the world beyond the academy.

Akoha – a Direct Action Game?

by Benjamin Stokes

How can we make everyday civic participation more compelling? There is a new kind of game on the horizon, one that experiments with real-world action. I call these “direct action games,” because they restructure acts like volunteering, activist training, and charitable giving. One prototype is Akoha, which started as a card game, then reinvented itself online, and last year launched a mobile app — largely off the radar of traditional civics organizations.

At first glance, Akoha looks like a media hub for some do-it-yourself Boy Scouts. Their website reveals thousands of participants, many reporting success with real-world “missions,” from going vegetarian for a day, to debating the “I Have a Dream” speech. The actual missions often take place offline, but are only rewarded if documented with photos and stories posted online or via iPhone.

I think Akoha deserves real attention as a working example — despite some prominent flaws. We desperately need concrete projects if we want to actually rethink civic life. The use of games to help “fix reality” has been a hot topic these past few weeks, thanks to the great traction of Jane McGonigal’s new book. Yet the missions of Akoha are more straightforward than most of Jane’s “alternate reality games,” which tend to have futuristic narratives, puppet masters behind the scenes, and a preference for crowd-sourcing. Thus I propose we look to Akoha and its more raw building blocks to think about direct action games.

Participants in Akoha are mostly adults, but the ages vary widely. The experience is deeply social, as friends create missions for each other, and share their stories. More formal recognition for participation comes as players earn badge-like awards — such as “multi-talented” for those who complete one mission in every possible category.

Most of Akoha does not look or sound civic. Only one of the mission categories explicitly addresses “social causes.” The other nine concern self-actualization in various forms, from “health and well-being” to family time, engaging with popular culture, and the discovery of travel. Is this breadth an upside or downside? That depends on your civic goals, which might include:

1. Fostering citizen journalism, as participants report on civic themes in their communities

2. Informal civic learning, as participants reflect on their civic experiences in new ways through stories and pictures

3. Building social capital, as participants create new ties across traditional social groups

These civic goals may be structurally possible with Akoha, but they are rhetorically hidden. Even as Akoha’s missions bring people into the real world, they avoid the “we are purely civic” framing that occurs on many activist and volunteering websites. For the Akoha community, it’s OK to admit that you are mainly there to have fun, or are trying to improve yourself (and not simply sacrificing for others). Consider this screenshot from the social cause mission “I Am Not an Island”:

mission-not-an-island-red1.jpg

Participation begins with the usual click of a button, yet the specific language of “Play Now” differs sharply from the tool focus of civic action websites (e.g., “Take Action Now;” or “Sign the Petition”). But what exactly does it mean to ‘play’ Akoha? Is it a game?

Certainly Akoha is recreational, and like all games, there are rules. In particular, participants must describe what they did to complete a mission, and thus must certify that they have met the terms set forth by the original mission author. Points and profiles track progress across the Akoha system. All players’ profiles feature their picture, personal statement, and a quantitative scoreboard — including their “player level,” number of missions completed, and awards. For a sense of what this looks like, here is one particularly high-achieving player, chosen from among the more than 10,000-plus who have registered:

profile-mgk-per-Dec21-2010-sm3.jpg

This public profile has evolved much as the community has coalesced. Just a few months prior, the player described himself in much more formal terms, emphasizing his offline profession — a “freelance Air conditioning and Refrigeration engineer by qualification and profession,” his belief in God, and how he found the site via Reader’s Digest. Now, in this recent screenshot, the player has removed his backstory, and describes instead how his Akoha playing strategy is driven by his personality. His refined self-presentation aligns with the pragmatics of the Akoha community, which focuses on choosing missions and writing stories — both depending more on personality than professional accomplishments outside the community.

Akoha is a designed system, and so I recently interviewed Alex Eberts, co-founder of Akoha and an influential force behind its design. He spoke of his desire to find “psychological drivers that are common to the real-world, and to game play.” His designs were informed by self-determination theory, which Eberts first came across in a session at the Game Developers Conference. (Academics, pay heed – these are not the usual dissemination channels for civic theory.)

Self-determination theory describes how human motivation is driven by basic human needs, including competence, autonomy, and relatedness. Altruism is not on the list of needs, just as it is not central to Akoha’s rhetoric. Pushing beyond traditional altruism in civic life is a theme that cuts across many of the projects we are tracking in Henry Jenkins’ Civic Paths research group — from the pop pleasure of Harry Potter, to the joy of diamonds as a precursor to political talk. Repositioning altruism is a battle, with fault lines between traditional civic organizations that have failed to engage youth, and new civic organizations that have failed to connect to politics. (See, for example, Bennett’s content analysis (pdf) of youth civic websites.)

Connecting games with the real-world necessitates a basic immediacy. This immediacy also distinguishes Akoha from most civic games, which focus on education for future civic life or future civic action. Here, the action and education are both in the present tense, which increases authenticity and the satisfaction of impact. The iPhone app for Akoha, released this past summer, underscores their immediacy — here is a set of screen shots they provide:

iphone-screenshots-sm.jpg

Using the mobile interface, Akoha missions can be documented on a bus in real-time, or browsed from a neighborhood park. Their mobile tech is fairly basic, consisting mainly of reskinning their existing website, with little use of GPS or other mobile sensor data. As a result, Akoha’s mobile interface is only minimally aware of the user’s location.

Place matters, especially in civics. (The neighborhood of our birth strongly predetermines a host of life opportunities, from income to education and governance.) This is an area for Akoha to grow. By improving their mobile support for place, its implications for civic activity would be more immediate and profound. In particular, Akoha might offer support for filtering missions for one’s own neighborhood, or connecting with players who are geographically nearby for joint missions, or simply allowing missions to release new clues when players arrive at specific locations.

Games are still discussed as individual indulgences. Yet increasingly, games are recognized as social forces. This is especially true for Akoha, where the social construction of value emerges over time, as a participant’s “friends” share stories about their missions and accomplishments. Different communities are likely to form over time. It is not yet clear whether Akoha is dominated by preexisting networks of offline friends, or by more interest-driven networks of people who gather around a shared passion. (This difference matters – see the ethnography of Ito et al.) Yet if Akoha can introduce strangers based on activity interests, the platform might transcend the left/right regression of civic talk that is so feared online by Sunstein.

Reimagining place is important civic work, just like the reimagining of societal values, tax policy, and even collective heroes. The value of games is to restructure this civic work around different rules – intrinsic motivations of the game, aligned with the desires of everyday people. Sometimes people want an excuse to be more civic. In my interview with Eberts, he confessed that one of the big surprises for his team was how much everyday people wanted Akoha to be even more civic. He hinted that future Akoha versions might well expand toward the civic.

Even as mobile has reshaped the everyday experiences of place and time, so too we may see game-like activities begin to restructure the experience of public participation. Yet Akoha remains an “edge phenomenon” to both the civic and gaming communities. In the first case, nonprofits are still trying to understand games for training, let alone for direct action; in the second, the independent gaming community is struggling to understand games for art, let alone games that improve the real world. Akoha is likely to be seen as a risky investment for funders in either community. Thus the evolving Akoha business model may be as crucial as its innovations in civic participation. For example, Eberts hints that corporate engagement may be an area of growth for such games.

Beyond Akoha, it might be useful to define a framework for direct action games. In a panel I organized last year at the Games for Change Festival, we explored the concept, and its historic manifestations; fellow panelists were game designer Tracy Fullerton and activist/scholar Stephen Duncombe (see embed below for video of the panel).

As we seek to define new templates for civic games, cases like Akoha help us prioritize research questions, including:

1. Can direct action games help us re-imagine civic activity under a different set of rules, solution frames, and feedback loops for engagement? (McGonigal’s aforementioned book nicely explores several of these philosophical questions.)

2. If only a portion of the activity is strictly civic, how do we compare to more traditional and pure civic engagement?

3. When is it appropriate to teach citizens how to “game the system” of democracy, to “win” in Akoha, or to rewrite the rules of local politics?

These issues will only become more important in coming months, as civic action goes digital and game culture grows. By examining cases like Akoha, we can develop frameworks for “direct action games” that better structure our civic designs.

Comments

  1. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

    Nikon CP1 Battery, Battery for Nikon CP1, Nikon CP1 Digital Camera Battery

  2. For me, the question is not whether serious games are effective (numerous studies have shown that they are) but how we can get people who would otherwise not play serious games to play them. One of the problems of applying self determination theory into game design is that it self-selects for the type of person who would play. This is great when you’re trying to gather people with similar motivations, like what Akoha is doing, but we should also be trying to design “good” games for people who would play the games not because they’re good, but because they are fun.

    It’s like vitamins for kids. The ones I used to take when I was young were chewable and cherry-flavored but I hated them and had to be forced by my parents. My niece, however, wants to take her vitamins because they are shaped like gummy bears and taste just as good. We need more gummy bear vitamin games.

  3. Too many social and economic issues remain “unsexy” to young people, and I blame the custodians of these fields for not making them more accessible and appealing. I think that any initiative that brings the slightest bit of awareness to these fields, and could possibly be used to recruit scholars, should be applauded. Like Yvette says, we need more gummy bear vitamin games.

  4. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!Olympus Camedia C-7000 Zoom

  5. shunmatt says:

    Fantastic post. Bookmarked this site 642-384 and emailed it to a few friends, your post was that great, keep it up.I am pretty much excited HP0-S27 thanks for sharing such a nice post. I really appreciate your way of presenting such 350-029 an excellent suggestion. I want more and i will come back here to see more updates in future 646-364 as well.my best wishes for you always so keep it up.regards

  6. I really love the theme of this site. The article is also very well written. I’m glad you have shared this topic to us.door alarms

  7. There are few things in life that are Cheap mbt footwear simply better in every way, and leave no room for argument. Mbt shoe for sale is one of them. This product, which does not depend on his appearance, but its Mbt online execution. This may be a good idea to test them on their feet.Company in thevibram MBT Chapa sale for over 70 years and is known for producing high quality footwear. MBT Fora are soft and supple nylon sole that can easily be extended to cover the contours of the legs to do. This is the only MBT Baridi, in one machine so that you keep them clean and fresh can be washed.If you have compiled one of those unfortunate set of MBT Imara shoes for long hours almost every day wear in your life, then you probably know how much load can MBT Kimondo shoes. People’s feet at least 26 bones, 33 joints, 20 muscles, and hundreds of sensory receptors, tendons and MBT Kisumu Sandals ligaments in this small space. He is not without reason, of course. Our feet are capable of great strength, speed, endurance, and it alone, we need to MBT M.Walk improve their potential. Barefoot and regularly ensure that our legs carried out in order to MBT Men’s Shoes enhance MBT Moja productivity. For runners and athletes who have MBT Sandals shoes, calf muscles, finally, to take the load MBT Sapatu pressure while the feet and toes curled up in a lather.We have MBT Shoes Clearance experienced a sudden resurgence of a large number of functions that We lost MBT Sini power years, our bodies move against nature. Gradually, we begin to bring our original way of MBT Sport walking, we used a pain in the muscles of the shin or on our waistline MBT Women’s Shoes disappears suddenly feeling that we are starting to Air Max feel particularly Nike Air Max 95 happy and free.

  8. Thank you for your charing . And your article is so well ,I will constant attention .At the same time ,I think there are many great things for you on my website ,and we will give you the surprise .Welcome to pandora beads on line store .

  9. http://www.findsoso.com

    hello everyone,im wholesale supplier online

    Welcome to our website

    ===== http://www.findsoso.com/ =======

    accept paypal or credit card and free shipping

    We need your support and trust!!!

    Dear friends, please temporarily stop your footsteps

    To our website Walk around A look at

    Maybe you’ll find happiness in your sight shopping heaven and earth

    You’ll find our price is more suitable for you.

  10. I’d been obsessed with my free porn videos younger sister’s sex life for almost two years when I finally found the courage and mobile porn the means to take a part in it. In fact, my obsession had probably been developing for quite some time before that without my noticing it free porn tube, my teenage unconscious taking in the form of her developing body, her budding breasts, her pheromones and whatnot since the onset of her puber

    ABB728019395

  11. I love your ideas of how you bring new faces to the entertainment world for future projects. It was nice to see your recent archive that has been posted in your blog. Good work

  12. Louis Vuitton, the world-renowned brands, but also for muxury a consideration. For these replica louis vuitton,replica Louis Vuitton Handbags absolute comw of NPK’s high quality and fashion design, but also added the popular bags for sale. There are also many copies of replica louis vuitton Handbag to sell in the market, so when you choose not to pay attention to your luggage. In addition, all of these Louis Vuitton Handbags,also used the same material,designed by replica louis vuitton of these condescending, and large bags. In short, all of these replica Louis Vuitton Handbags to provide you with the replica louis vuitton Handbag and so on. Speaking of Louis Vuitton Handbags,people know, talk, and only those women who use this wealth of high-priced bags. In the winter, it is said, the work of louis vuitton travel luggage and louis vuitton men bags in these cities on the market very well.

    CHEN

  13. fashionb says:

    In the rounds to promote his film “Black Swan, almost no significant actress Winonahttp://lingeriebras.net“ title=”sexy lingerie”>sexy lingerie

    http://lingeriescorset.net“ title=”sexy lingerie”>sexy lingerie morning conversation in the UK,

    http://sexylingeriecorset.net“ title=”sexy lingerie”>sexy lingerie wearing a less than flattering

    http://lingeriescorset.org“ title=”sexy lingerie”>sexy lingerie in the upper part of

    http://lingeriebras.org“ title=”sexy lingerie”>sexy lingerie the morning.

    http://sexylingeriecorset.org“ title=”sexy lingerie”>sexy lingerie

  14. I agree. A comment should say more than just great post. In fact, why would you say great post without explaining your reason behind your words? Why not back up what you’re saying and get people to interact with that? If you’re going to leave a comment it’s because you want to express how you feel to the author of the post and to whomever may read your comment and decide to add on to it further.

    curt

    Nike Air Max Wavy

  15. robertmatt says:

    This post is exactly what I am interested. I shall be pleased 640-553 IINS to become a regular visitor. keep up the good work. we need more good statements. i have bookmarked 640-721 IUWNE your site for future reference. Please add more good information 646-364 CXFA that would help others in such good way.i will come back here to see more updates in future 642-384 CXFF as well.my best wishes for you always so keep it up. best regards

    Good website, I discover very good and informative 646-671 AWLANAM post! keep up the good work. we need more good statements. Keep it up. i have bookmarked 642-456 CIPT2 your site for future reference I really appreciate your way of presenting 646-230 AUCAM such an excellent suggestion. I want more and i will come back here to see more updates in future 642-583 SSSE as well.my best wishes for you always so keep it up.regards regards

  16. welcome great web for shopping text to speech and rolex replicaShop and find the lowest prices on products from louis vuitton outlet. Price comparison shopping, product reviews, and armani watch – all the tools to help make wow gold simple

  17. If you are not able to find the required parts then you can call our toll free 1-888-907-7225 support lines and get guidance from our support experts. Usually, we will deliver the ordered parts from our warehouse nearest to your place and you can receive at your place without any delay. AC Condenser

  18. You raise some interesting points on your article and I look forward to reading your next post on the subject.

    guitar forum

  19. Lovely job

    x pole

    x pole

    office ma

  20. PornoPixel is Seo Friendly and to improve backlinks, for sites that have purchased the pixels, their links are appears on the popular Social Network, Blog and Service. (with a single purchase) Start Advertising

  21. shawnlee says:

    If you are not able to find the required parts then you can call our toll free 1-888-907-7225 support lines and get guidance from our support experts. Usually, we will deliver the ordered parts from our warehouse nearest to your place and you can receive at your place without any delay.test king \ microsoft dumps \ a+ certification \ ase certification \ ccda certification \ ccent practice exam

  22. bogeyman says:

    Testkings is appreciative to advertise the new and arising certifications alertness guides and braindumps with appropriate abatement for their registered candidates and for new candidates alone for bound time of period. Don’t decay your time, abstraction by testking’s provided assay alertness kit, save money and access your certifications with accomplished scores. By the Grace of Almighty God, our braindumps are broadly acclimated by the IT able common and humans like to acquirement braindumps and convenance analysis from testking. You will not alone canyon your acceptance assay but, enhance your ability and abilities about the assay artefact you are traveling to pursue.

    LX0-101 | E20-322 | HP2-T16 | 000-037 | 000-087 | NS0-153 | ST0-91W | 642-973 | 642-504 | 642-982

  23. C5-Coach outlet store online

    Have your buy your lovely bag in Coach Outlet,may be not,Coach Factory Outlet is a great way to get amazing http://www.coachoutlet-storeonlines.com/coach-purses-c-72.html ” rel=”nofollow”>Cheap Coach Purse,and you can totally bought it in Coach Outlet Online , Coach Outlet Online Store is a new way to get elegant coach bags,you don't need to get outdoor,just sit before your computer,and than you can get the one you like best,and thire are always original,so come to Coach Outlet Store ,click here to go to Coach Outlet Store Online,perfect shopping time is waitting for you.

  24. Great information, thanks for sharing cheap ugg boots

  25. url,[url=http://www.coachs-factorystore…]Coach Factory Store[/url],a title h1,<h1>Chanel Purses</h1>.a title,Coach Factory Store,a h1.<h1>Coach Outlet</h1>.a, the one,
    Coach Factory Store.

  26. Women are born to beautiful, born of shopping,.Go shopping in people's eyes is women's patent as if .Now a new choice for women is going to Coach Factory Online.If you want to buy Coach Poppy Bag or Coach Wallet, but don't want to go out, Coach Factory Outlet must be your best choice, why buy Coach from us? Because we have all kinds of Coach products,and these products are high quality and low price.Coach Factory provide the most perfect service, your order will arrive about 5~7days.Free shipping any order of $99+. Coach bags sell 75% off which in Coach Factory Online Are you still hesitate? To click on your mouse to choose your like.Welcome to Coach Factory Outlet!

    Coach Outlet Online is coming this world now!Coach bags,most famous brand in usa,also the world,why are coach spread so wide,that is because cheap with fashion,the reason why is so cheap because coach always have Coach Outlet,Coach Outlet Online is the Online shop of Coach Bags,and they take their product all is from Coach Outlet Online Store,no tax no room rent is the advance of Coach Outlet Online Store,so come and shopping us now,beautiful bag are waitting for you.

    Everybody should have a beautiful Coach Bag.Where can we buy Coach Outlet bags? A lot of people choose to go to Coach Outlet Store Online.All products what sale in Coach Outlet Online are top quality and low price.We promise you to recieve your buy about 5~7days. Coach Outlet Store Online directly sell for customers.Do you want to free to buy Coach Bags in your home?Please click Coach Outlet Online.

    Coach Outlet Store Online is cheapest mall to bought Coach bags,as a famous brand in the world,have discount is a incredible thing.Find Coach Outlet Online is a new way to get Coach Bags,Coach Outlet Online obviously is a perfect way to get it,in this winter are you really ready to be a fashion women,Coach Outlet will help you,so join us now! Coach Outlet Store Online wating for you comeing!

    Hermes Handbags is the most valuable bag in fashion world, as the world’s most expensive brand, if you have one, that must stand that you are a good station person in your country, Hermes is famous of it’s Hermes Handbags , as the hermes handbag’s high qulity and best design, maybe the price is the best in the world.Two series of hermes is popular, that is Hermes Kelly Bags , and Hermes Birkin Bags , this two series make Hermes more popular, so visit our site to get elegant Hermes Bags.

    Louis Vuitton Online Store are amazing shopping site in this world, because through it, you can bought the Louis Vuitton Outlet handbag in an incredible price, maybe a new way to get Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbag, that is Louis Vuitton Online Store, as I understand they take the bag from Louis vuitton factory, no tax, no house rent, no compete, these make the price lower then louis vuitton shop, so why not shop the Louis Vuitton Online, amazing Louis Vuitton handbag are belong to you.

    Belstaff Jackets is the most popular winter brand in the world,if you don't know,that means you out.Belstaff Coat is famous of its high-level material and fahisonable design,so that's why so many people choose Belstaff to though the cold winter.Nowaday surffing the internet is the lifestyle of most people,but have you bought things on the internet,I introduce you to try to buy things in the internet,because you can buy Belstaff Sale on the internet,that way you can get big discount than in reality world,in the brand Belstaff Jacket series is the hottest,this series suit for all kinds of people,whatever you like,whatever you are,you suit it,so buy Belstaff Jackets on internet now,you will shocked for it.

    The winter is comming,have you prepared to pass the winter,I think a Moncler Jackets is necessaery,Online Moncler is a good way to get a perfect Moncler Jackets way,Moncler is famous of it amazing qulity and it's consummate manual work,when you ware it,you will feel warm,whatere how cold the winter is,Moncler can take care of your body.Our Online Monclerafford latest Moncler Coat,so in the cold winter you can also fashion and attractive,so visit our Moncler Online Shop,it will take you a warm winter.

    The chrishmas is comming,do you want to make your holiday colourful and unexpensive,yes,Hermes Handbags is waiting for you.maybe Hermes Handbags is very expensive,but you will be interisted in our Replica Hermes Handbags,we have Hermes Birkin Bags,Hermes Kelly Bags and so on,all of them is quality assured and beautiful,so buy Hermes Replica Handbag on our site,amazing surprise is waiting for you.

  27. Huaxiangseo says:

    TRIPOLI (Reuters) -Christian Louboutin Two British journalists detained by a Libyan militia last month and accused of spying have been released and cleared of all charges,Christian Louboutin Shoes an interior ministry official said on Sunday.Nicholas Davies-Jones and Gareth Montgomery-Johnson, Christian Louboutin Sale who were working for Iran's English-language Press TV, were detained on February 22 by the Swehli brigade,Cheap Christian Louboutin one of dozens of militias which last year helped force out Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi.Earlier this month,Christian Louboutin On Sale the Swehli militia said the Britons, initially detained for illegal entry into Libya, were suspected of spying.Both men were transferred to the custody of the government this week.Christian Louboutin Cheap They have been released and tomorrow they will leave the country,” Abed al-Menemayad, head of the media and international cooperation office at the interior ministry,Red Bottoms told Reuters.The British consul received them and the charges against them have been dropped,” he added, without giving details.Christian Louboutin Outlet The British embassy in Tripoli said it was aware of reports of the men's release.On Tuesday,http://www.christian-louboutin-shoes-online.com/ the militia released a video of the two journalists in which the men apologized for entering Libya illegally.