From a Cyberspace of Their Own to Television 2.0: An Interview with Rhianon Bury (Part One)

Several months ago, I was contacted by Rhianon Bury, an early contributor to the scholarly research on female online fan communities through her book, A Cyberspace of Their Own, asking me to help her publicize a survey she was conducting on how fans engaged with new delivery platforms for television content.

Bury agreed to do an interview for my blog which deals with this new initiative and what it means in terms of her own methodological approaches (an expansion from primarily ethnographic to a more hybrid approach), as well as shifts in the field of fan studies and new media since 2005 when her book first appeared. Like many of us, Bury is finding it hard to separate out the study of media audiences, creative industries, and new media practices, at a time when some aspects of fan culture have become more central to the operations of convergence culture, while, as many recent scholars note, others remain marginalized and in some cases, continue to be fully hidden from outside attention.

You have recently launched an online survey designed to better understand the shift in the media consumption patterns of fans in response to the changing affordances of the new media environment. What kinds of shifts are you hoping to explore?

I am interested in learning more about shifts in both modes of viewing and fan practices afforded by time shifting, streaming, downloading and Web 2.0 technologies. Industry data has provided a starting point for my “Television 2.0″ project. According to Nielsen, 38 percent of US households now have DVR/PVRs, up from 33 percent in 2009 and 24.4 percent in 2008 (TVbytheNumbers). In addition to its traditional Live data stream, Nielsen produces two additional streams: Live+SD (same day) and Live+7 (seven days). Although the latter are not significant in setting advertising rates, their effects are starting to be felt in network decision making. Writing in the New York Times, Bill Carter suggests that NBC’s The Event was spared early cancellation on the strength of its Live+7 numbers. NBC subsequently ordered a full season, although it remains to be seen whether all will be broadcast given that the live/live+sd numbers continue to fall (Toni Fitzgerald).

A number of recent surveys by marketing research companies attempt to quantify the popularity of viewing of time shifted and online content. Say Media, for example, found that 56 million Americans are “off the grid viewers,” 13 percent of whom can be classified as “opt outs” who have no longer watch live TV at all (GigaOM). This matches Strategy Analytics findings that 13 percent of Americans are planning to cancel their cable subscription in the next year. The large majority of “cord cutters” are under 40 and are college educated.

This type of industry data, however, cannot capture the complexity of viewer and fan engagement with multiple screens and platforms. I want to know how much television programming people are watching in front of the television screen, the computer screen and/or on a mobile device. I also want to learn more about what kinds of programming people watch (and rewatch) on which platform(s) and under what circumstances. Television programming is not a homogenous category and viewing is not a homogenous activity.

In terms of media fandom, anecdotally we know social media looms large. Web analytics software can quantify views, hits and clicks of primary and ancillary content on network sites, Hulu, and YouTube. The resulting data, however, tells us very little about the heterogeneity of fandom in terms of the range of practices that fans engage in (or not) and their varying levels of investments and involvement in participatory cultures.

Until now, you have been seen primarily as a qualitative researcher. What has motivated you to adopt a more quantitative approach to this project?

First of all, I am trying to fill what I see as a large gap in the study of fan and participatory cultures. It is of great concern to me that eighteen years after the publication of your very important work, Textual Poachers, no large-scale quantitative academic studies have been conducted. Without valid and reliable data, we cannot make generalizable claims about fan practices. We know fans watch television programming on a variety of platforms, go to cons, participate in online discussion forums, are members of online fan communities, read and write fiction, make vids, live tweet episodes, etc., but we have no idea how widespread these practices actually are among the fan population to use research terminology. Getting a snapshot of this population is not only interesting but critical to establishing a legitimate field of study, at least in the social sciences.

Moreover, unlike my previous research, my starting point is not a particular fandom but rather the individual viewer/fan. There is a tendency among fan scholars to study the fandoms of which they are a part. Methodologically, there’s nothing wrong with this choice as long as one is sufficiently reflexive. Such an approach also foregrounds research questions on community and community making. I’m sure we all know people who really enjoy particular television shows but who don’t actually do much more than watch the show, talk about it face-to-face, add it to their list of “likes” on Facebook and/or go to the broadcasting network website on occasion.

The Television 2.0 project is actually a mixed methods study. I will be doing not only a quantitative analysis of the data collected in the survey but a qualitative one as well. The second phase will consist of follow up interviews with interested survey respondents, starting (I hope) in early 2011. I still consider myself primarily a qualitative researcher because my interest in measurement is not an end in itself.

You published Cyberspaces of Their Own: Female Fandoms Online in 2005 and it reflects research done much earlier than that. What do you see as the biggest changes in online fandom over that time?

It’s hard to believe that almost fifteen years have passed since I started working with members of the David Duchovny Estrogen Brigades (DDEBs). In the preface to Cyberspaces, I recounted first discovering their websites using a lynx browser on Mozilla using a monochrome monitor. I can’t even visualize that interface today!

Beyond the obvious technological changes, one of the biggest shifts has been in the gender composition of fan-based cyberspaces. Research on internet access and use shows that gender parity was reached around 2000 in North America. Would the DDEBs be set up as private female-only listservs today? I doubt it, not because listserv technology is obsolete (at least for this purpose), but because the Usenet group (alt.tv.x-files) where the founding members originally met likely would have had far more participation from women, thereby “diluting” the sexist attitudes of more vocal male members of that forum. In other words, the practices engaged in by the majority of members would have created different community standards or norms.

More significantly, online X-Files fandom would not have been concentrated in one space. A range of alternatives would have been available: discussion forums on Fox and Television Without Pity; LiveJournal and Dreamwidth, particularly for fan fiction writers and vidders; Second Life and Facebook. Fans who had felt personal affinities with others on the various forums they visited would have become personal Facebook friends. Earlier this year, I reconnected with some of my research participants from the DDEBs on Facebook, which has been fun. And just this week, I read the status update from one of the members of the original DDEB indicating that she has created a private Facebook group for the community.

A second major shift that I would like to mention is related to the production of television’s secondary texts or paratexts. There was been a lot of “industry creep” into the areas that were once exclusively the domain of fans. Most networks host discussion boards and produce a range of ancillary content for their series websites, including quizzes, polls, games, as well as facebook pages and twitter feeds. The reasons for this move are obvious: fans are also consumers and media content producers want to foster fan loyalties to their brand. Combine easily accessible sites with the power of Google and YouTube, the latter which allows for far wider distribution of fan vids than in the past, and the result is a multiplicity of entry points into fandom.

Rhiannon Bury is an Assistant Professor of Women’s and Gender Studies at Athabasca University, Canada’s Open University. Her research interests include communication technologies, identity and community, and media fan culture. Her book, Cyberspaces of Their Own, was published by Peter Lang in 2005. She is currently collecting data for her Television 2.0 project. To take the survey, visit here. Check out her blog.

Comments

  1. From a Cyberspace of Their Own to Television 2.0: An Interview with Rhianon Bury (Part One) good article for your post visit to my blog

    perlunya web komunitas event

    perlunya web komunitas event

  2. Charlote says:

    I am student of HP0-D07 and 642-456 and also love to reading blogs , because there are many new information and updates like 70-686 and 1z0-052 your article have good information I like it thanks for sharing. I visit this site interesting blogs ever much viewed, after a long time.

  3. Hi I found this site by mistake when i was searching Google aboutcoach bags, I must say your site is really helpful for me to learn of discount coach bags , its amazing!. I don’t have the time at the moment to fully read your site but I have bookmarked it and also signed up for your RSS feeds. I will be back in a day or two. thanks for a great site about coach designer handbags.

  4. I’d been obsessed with my free porn videos younger sister’s sex life for almost two years when I finally found the courage and mobile porn the means to take a part in it. In fact, my obsession had probably been developing for quite some time before that without my noticing it free porn tube, my teenage unconscious taking in the form of her developing body, her budding breasts, her pheromones and whatnot since the onset of her puber

    ABB728019395

  5. Cheap Bags Handbags,Cheap Nike Air Max, Cheap Air Jordans…

    High replicas Online Store

    cheap clothes

    cheap nike max shoes

    cheap handbags

    High quality guaranteed. Wholesale Price offered.

    China Wholesale Branded Handbags,Branded handbags are usually expensive and unaffordable for us common people. While here we offer a wide range of designer handbags replicas, high quality guaranteed. Amazing cheap handbags. Cheap Fashion Coach Women’s Bags

    Coach handbags are one of the best sellers here, even around the world. Wanna be in fashion, you should own a Coach bag in your wordrobe.

    Hot Selling Gucci Women’s Handbags, Gucci bags has a lot of fans from all over the world. Top Quality Juicy Couture Tote/Shoulder Bags

    Juicy is a brand that designed for sweety girls. With it’s lovely design and it’s changeable colors, it has won a lot of favor from ladies aroung the world.

    Cheapest Designer Clothing for sale. Branded t-shirts, shirts, jeans, outerwear, suits etc. many styles for your selection. Buy Discount Jewelry Online Shiny Jewelry that you should own at least one piece. That’s one of the necessary equipment for you.

  6. discountcoachbags says:

    I must say your site is really helpful for me to learn of discount coach bags

  7. cheapcoachhandbags says:
  8. cheapcoachhandbags says:
  9. designercoachhandbags says:
  10. designercoachhandbags says:
  11. PornoPixel is Seo Friendly and to improve backlinks, for sites that have purchased the pixels, their links are appears on the popular Social Network, Blog and Service. (with a single purchase) Start Advertising

  12. Great information, thanks so much ugg boots

  13. Women are born to beautiful, born of shopping,.Go shopping in people's eyes is women's patent as if .Now a new choice for women is going to Coach Factory Online.If you want to buy Coach Poppy Bag or Coach Wallet, but don't want to go out, Coach Factory Outlet must be your best choice, why buy Coach from us? Because we have all kinds of Coach products,and these products are high quality and low price.Coach Factory provide the most perfect service, your order will arrive about 5~7days.Free shipping any order of $99+. Coach bags sell 75% off which in Coach Factory Online Are you still hesitate? To click on your mouse to choose your like.Welcome to Coach Factory Outlet!

    Coach Outlet Online is coming this world now!Coach bags,most famous brand in usa,also the world,why are coach spread so wide,that is because cheap with fashion,the reason why is so cheap because coach always have Coach Outlet,Coach Outlet Online is the Online shop of Coach Bags,and they take their product all is from Coach Outlet Online Store,no tax no room rent is the advance of Coach Outlet Online Store,so come and shopping us now,beautiful bag are waitting for you.

    Everybody should have a beautiful Coach Bag.Where can we buy Coach Outlet bags? A lot of people choose to go to Coach Outlet Store Online.All products what sale in Coach Outlet Online are top quality and low price.We promise you to recieve your buy about 5~7days. Coach Outlet Store Online directly sell for customers.Do you want to free to buy Coach Bags in your home?Please click Coach Outlet Online.

    Coach Outlet Store Online is cheapest mall to bought Coach bags,as a famous brand in the world,have discount is a incredible thing.Find Coach Outlet Online is a new way to get Coach Bags,Coach Outlet Online obviously is a perfect way to get it,in this winter are you really ready to be a fashion women,Coach Outlet will help you,so join us now! Coach Outlet Store Online wating for you comeing!

    Hermes Handbags is the most valuable bag in fashion world, as the world’s most expensive brand, if you have one, that must stand that you are a good station person in your country, Hermes is famous of it’s Hermes Handbags , as the hermes handbag’s high qulity and best design, maybe the price is the best in the world.Two series of hermes is popular, that is Hermes Kelly Bags , and Hermes Birkin Bags , this two series make Hermes more popular, so visit our site to get elegant Hermes Bags.

    Louis Vuitton Online Store are amazing shopping site in this world, because through it, you can bought the Louis Vuitton Outlet handbag in an incredible price, maybe a new way to get Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbag, that is Louis Vuitton Online Store, as I understand they take the bag from Louis vuitton factory, no tax, no house rent, no compete, these make the price lower then louis vuitton shop, so why not shop the Louis Vuitton Online, amazing Louis Vuitton handbag are belong to you.

    Belstaff Jackets is the most popular winter brand in the world,if you don't know,that means you out.Belstaff Coat is famous of its high-level material and fahisonable design,so that's why so many people choose Belstaff to though the cold winter.Nowaday surffing the internet is the lifestyle of most people,but have you bought things on the internet,I introduce you to try to buy things in the internet,because you can buy Belstaff Sale on the internet,that way you can get big discount than in reality world,in the brand Belstaff Jacket series is the hottest,this series suit for all kinds of people,whatever you like,whatever you are,you suit it,so buy Belstaff Jackets on internet now,you will shocked for it.

    The winter is comming,have you prepared to pass the winter,I think a Moncler Jackets is necessaery,Online Moncler is a good way to get a perfect Moncler Jackets way,Moncler is famous of it amazing qulity and it's consummate manual work,when you ware it,you will feel warm,whatere how cold the winter is,Moncler can take care of your body.Our Online Monclerafford latest Moncler Coat,so in the cold winter you can also fashion and attractive,so visit our Moncler Online Shop,it will take you a warm winter.

    The chrishmas is comming,do you want to make your holiday colourful and unexpensive,yes,Hermes Handbags is waiting for you.maybe Hermes Handbags is very expensive,but you will be interisted in our Replica Hermes Handbags,we have Hermes Birkin Bags,Hermes Kelly Bags and so on,all of them is quality assured and beautiful,so buy Hermes Replica Handbag on our site,amazing surprise is waiting for you.

  14. PDF Password Recovery for Mac is a small, easy-to-use yet professional tool to recover PDF password and restrictions. With PDF Password Remover for mac, you can remove pdf copying and printing restrictions, and open password from encrypted PDF files effortlessly and directly. PDF Password Recovery gives Mac Users a solution to unlock protected PDF files without requiring the password, which provides a way to help users to remove PDF document password and protections quickly when losing PDF passwords protection. Mac PDF Password Recovery works fast and supports batch decrypting up to 50 simultaneously.

    This PDF Password Recovery for Mac can also remove owner password which is used to protect PDF files from editing, copying and printing and remove user password which is used to protect PDF files from opening. For owner password, Mac PDF Password Recovery can remove it directly without requiring the password, but if the PDF files are encrypted by user password, you need the authorized password to remove PDF DRM Mac OS X.

    PDF Password Cracker for Mac is the best Mac PDF Password Removal in the market now. This smart mac pdf password cracking software embodies its professional functions in many ways such as Remove copying and printing restrictions from encrypted PDF files directly, Remove open password from encrypted PDF files (with authorized password), Support batch decrypting 50 PDF files at one time, Decrypt a 500-page encrypted PDF file within 1 minute, Support drag-and-drop operation, etc.

    Batch decryption and drag-and-drop operation offered by PDF Password Cracker for Mac will save Mac users lots of precious time by quickly recovering PDF documents when losing copying and printing PDF passwords.

    PDF Password Remover for Mac is a small yet powerful PDF password removing application which can be used to crack password protected Adobe Reader PDF by removing the “owner password” used for protecting PDF files from editing, copying, printing, selecting text and graphics (and copying them into the Clipboard), or adding/changing annotations and form fields in seconds. Afterwards, the decrypted PDF can be read in any PDF Reader(e.g. Adobe Acrobat Reader of all versions) without any restrictions.

    Secondly, PDF Password Remover for Mac allows you to unlock PDF “user password” with the premise of knowing the open password to make the decrypted PDF document unprotected from the moment. Supported by batch-decryption, Drag and Drop, various PDF formats and languages, Mac users can open kinds of encrypted PDF file rapidly in full quality within only three steps, thus greatly improving our work efficiency.